Water Heater Repair in Dallastown, PA
More than half of Dallastown's homes are rented, and one in three was built before 1940. Most heat with gas, and two gas companies list the borough. If your water heater has quit or is leaking, call and get a plumber out.
What shapes water heater trouble in Dallastown
A borough of renters
About 55% of Dallastown homes are rented. About 23% are rowhomes or twins and 20% are in buildings with five or more units. The borough requires every residential rental unit to be registered and inspected. For 2026, registration was $100 per unit, due by February 28, with a $10 late fee added for each month after that.
The borough's rental code also sets minimum safety devices: a carbon monoxide detector in any common hallway leading to sleeping areas and at least one on every level. That matters with a gas water heater in the basement. If you rent and the hot water goes out, or the CO alarm sounds, tell your landlord or the owner's agent, and for a CO alarm, get everyone outside first.
Red Lion's water, the borough's pipes
The Dallastown-Yoe Water Authority owns the pipes that serve Dallastown, Yoe and part of York Township, but it buys all of its water from the Red Lion Municipal Authority. That water comes mainly from the Cabin Creek reservoir, with Beaver Creek added when demand is high and a Susquehanna River pump station held for drought. The authority has also published a service line inventory, so you can look up what your line is made of.
After a main break on West Broad Street on January 16, 2026, the authority's advice was to open an outside faucet for a few seconds once water came back, to clear air and dirt from the line. During hydrant flushing in May 2026, the borough said to make sure the water wasn't discolored before doing laundry. Both are good habits for a water heater too: clear the cold lines first, so dirt doesn't get pulled into the tank.
Two gas companies, older houses
About 57% of Dallastown homes heat with gas and 36% with electricity. UGI lists Dallastown Borough in its York County region, and Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania lists it in its service area too, so your bill tells you which company is yours. That matters for outages and leaks. In January 2019, a Columbia Gas outage left many Dallastown customers without gas overnight while service was restored.
When gas comes back after an outage, a gas water heater has to be relit. If the pilot won't stay lit afterward, the thermocouple or gas valve may have been on its way out. With a median build year of 1958 and a third of homes from before 1940, plenty of gas heaters here still vent into an old chimney, so a replacement should include a look at the vent too.
Safe steps for Dallastown homes
- Leaking? Close the cold water valve on top of the tank.
- Turn off the gas valve or the breaker for the heater.
- Gas smell? UGI and Columbia Gas both list Dallastown. If you smell gas, leave the house, then call UGI at 800-276-2722, Columbia Gas at 888-460-4332, or 911 from outside.
Repair, replacement and emergencies
Water Heater Repair
Gas, electric and tankless repairs, from pilot lights to heating elements.
Learn more
No Hot Water
Cold shower this morning? Get the cause found and fixed fast.
Learn more
Leaking Water Heater
Water around the tank or a dripping relief valve. Act before it floods.
Learn more
Emergency Water Heater Repair
Burst tank, gas smell or water everywhere. Call right away.
Learn more
Water Heater Replacement
When repair no longer makes sense, get a new tank or tankless unit.
Learn more
Tankless Water Heater Repair
Error codes, lukewarm water and scale buildup on tankless units.
Learn moreDallastown water heater questions
Who is the gas company in Dallastown?
It depends on your street. UGI and Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania both list Dallastown in their territories. Your gas bill shows which one serves you.
Where does Dallastown's water come from?
The Dallastown-Yoe Water Authority buys all of its water from the Red Lion Municipal Authority, which draws mainly from the Cabin Creek reservoir.
Do Dallastown landlords have to register rentals?
Yes. Every residential rental unit must be registered and inspected. For 2026 the fee was $100 per unit, due February 28, with a $10 monthly late fee.
What should I do after a water main break in Dallastown?
The water authority suggests opening an outside faucet for a few seconds once water returns, to clear air and dirt. Run cold water clear before using hot.
Where these local facts come from
- US Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020-2024 (via Census Reporter)
- UGI Utilities, gas supply regions
- Columbia Gas of Pennsylvania, service territories
- York Daily Record, natural gas service being restored to Dallastown customers (Jan. 5, 2019)
- Dallastown-Yoe Water Authority, 2025 annual drinking water quality report
- Dallastown Borough, Dallastown-Yoe Water Authority (debt service charge, reports)
- Dallastown-Yoe Water Authority, water main break on W Broad St (Jan. 16, 2026)
- Dallastown Borough, 2026 spring and summer newsletter (hydrant flushing, rental units)
- Dallastown Borough, 2026 rental registration application and Chapter 151 fire safety devices
- Dallastown Borough Code, Chapter 151: Rental Properties
Figures are the latest published by each source. Pricing and availability are set by the plumber.
No hot water in Dallastown?
Call now for water heater repair or replacement.